Exploring the Top Neighborhoods to Live in Long Island, NY

Long Island, New York, stands out as a magnificent island globally, housing a significant portion of New York City’s population and numerous esteemed companies. Long Island is truly a wonderful place. Nevertheless, not everyone has a say in deciding where they reside. There are numerous fantastic neighborhoods to choose from, making it difficult to know where to start. Here is a list to guide you to the top neighborhoods on Long Island.

Which is the top location to reside on Long Island?

Long Island is an ideal place for families, residents, or retirees. Each area has its own special charm. Long Island’s towns provide a range of options, from peaceful settings to vibrant communities, catering to various preferences. Long Island, NY, is a stunning island where one-third of New Yorkers reside. For young professionals living independently, couples starting a family, or commuters sharing with roommates, there’s a Long Island neighborhood to fit every lifestyle.


Bellmore is a great choice for those who appreciate a peaceful community environment. Jones Beach Park is a top attraction in the area, known as one of the best beaches in New York state. Renting a one-bedroom apartment in Bellmore typically costs around $1,800 per month. The average rent price has stayed consistent since 2021.

Bellmore is recognized for its strong focus on education and is also featured on this list. Bellmore and Merrick have a shared school system, allowing your children to access excellent education without the high expenses of Merrick.


Zillow reports that the average selling price of a home in Massapequa is $652,524. Property prices in Massapequa have increased by 11.2% since 2021. Massapequa is an excellent choice for families due to its top-rated school system. This area offers a wide range of outdoor leisure activities. Massapequa Cove, a popular fishing spot in the New York City area, is conveniently located near the local parks. Massapequa is a high-end neighborhood with opportunities for relaxation and education.


Huntington is a town located in Suffolk County on Long Island. In April 2022, the average listing price for a property in Huntington, New York, stood at $796,900. This represents a 16% growth compared to 2021. Huntington offers a variety of boutiques, local markets, restaurants, and a lively nightlife.

This large town in Suffolk is one of the largest and remains famous beyond New York. If you enjoy live music, fine dining, and vibrant nightlife, Huntington is the place for you. Nevertheless, it’s not all about the glitz and glamour.

Also Read: Listing 5 Richest Neighborhoods in Chicago for 2024


Smithtown boasts a close-knit community despite its compact population. It’s situated approximately 50 miles to the north of Manhattan, right in the center of the North Shore. Typically, a one-bedroom apartment in Smithtown rents for approximately $2,934 per month. Smithtown is famous for its craft beers, dining options, and one-of-a-kind stores. There are numerous parks in the area, such as Caleb Smith State Park.

Even though the town is small, it has a strong sense of community where everyone is familiar with each other and works together to create a better future. Expect small shops, well-stocked eateries, and a community ethos focused on teamwork. If you’re looking for a neighborhood on Long Island with a strong sense of community, this location might be the right fit for you.

Stony Brook

Stony Brook used to be a favorite spot for tourists due to its picturesque beauty. Today, the region has also transformed into a sought-after residential area with excellent schools and a nearby college for further education. Typically, one-bedroom apartments in Stony Brook go for about $2,310 per month. The average rent cost has not changed since 2021.


Merrick, situated at the southern tip of Long Island, is well-known for its beautiful beaches and sunny weather. Merrick provides a perfect balance between suburban living and easy access to New York City (just a 45-minute train ride away). The area’s charm includes sophisticated homes, beachside fun, and vibrant nightlife.

Merrick is considered one of the safest boroughs in New York City, with an average house price of $708,851. Merrick is the ideal choice if you are looking for a high-quality educational system. This community is recognized for its top-notch school system on Long Island, which produces highly respected graduates.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.